Hi there, the Arcadia is an excellent uvb bulb. The other bulb is " O.K." but only produces an intense sp[ot of heat. You'd do better with a 100 or 150 halogen bulb or other incandescent [ old style ] household bulb that projects light + heat to a further range.
I totally agree, the Arcadia tubes are terrific! You can't go wrong with them.
The basking light would be fine, but you might like a flood bulb better it would be much
brighter.