Hiya,
First of all, nice to see another great lakes person.
I'm up in Michigan, used to work with water samples from Lake Erie for my job during undergraduate (I was looking at viruses and free-living fungi at the time).
For cleaning object like this I always recommend treating them the same way I would in a lab, but that's likely because I'm a lab person, lol. First wash them with clean water and a brush to remove any dirt/debris from the surface, then soak for a few minutes (5-10) in a low-concentration bleach wash (about a tablespoon per gallon of water should work, that's slightly stronger than you would use for baby bottles, etc. You could probably go up to 10% safely, but if you're in the great lakes region there's probably going to be a relatively low abundance of reptile pathogens to be concerned about with your BD). Remove from bleach solution and rinse completely 3-6 times with clean water. Finally, submerge in water treated with 1.5-2 times the recommended amount of reptisafe or similar product. Finally, drain and lay on a dry, absorbent surface in a single layer and allow to air-dry for 24-48 hours. Ideally, this would be done under sunlight.
There's a lot of products out there that would work great, though, like the F10 someone recommended.
Another really good option would be boiling them for 10 minutes in a large, sturdy pot after scrubbing them free of dirt/debris and then allowing them to cool and air dry.
Hope this helps,
-Ellen