Hi,
So, first of all, I want to say that the topic of your post is 100% correct and I don't disagree with you at all. The whole "
hydration through cloaca" thing is absolute bunk, and I'm glad you posted about it!
However, I do want to address one of the reasons a vet might recommend bathes for a dehydrated dragon. We all know the importance of substrate regarding fecal impaction, however a lesser known cause or co-cause impaction is dehydration. Many studies even site chronic dehydration as a more common cause of impaction than improper substrate. Additionally, as many of us are familiar, most Bearded Dragons love to poop in their bathwater because they're weird, gross little animals. In fact a common first-response treatment to most cases of impaction will generally be a long, warm soak. This treatment is often quite successful, particularly in cases of impaction that are caused by dehydration (and therefor hard urates) as opposed to foreign bodies like the impaction caused by the consumption of sand or other loose substrates.
Because of this, making sure to give appropriate bathes to a dehydrated dragon is an entirely appropriate care measure. The bathes themselves are not so much to fix the primary issue of dehydration as to prevent/treat one of the most deadly symptoms of dehydration - impaction. Especially since it may take a little time for orally administered fluids to affect this particular aspect of the problem the bathes help prevent other treatments providing
hydration from becoming "too little, too late" if the dragon's dehydration was causing impaction.
While it sounds like in your case your vet explicitly said the
bath was to re-
hydrate your dragon as opposed to help with it's bowel movements, I just thought I would share this nugget of information to anyone reading so they don't ignore vet's orders. Essentially I believe your vet was giving you a correct treatment for incorrect reasons. Regardless, I hope your dragon is doing better!
Hope this is helpful,
-Ellen
Some sources on dehydration and impaction:
1) "
Two Common Disorders of Captive Bearded Dragons (Pogona vitticeps): Nutritional Secondary Hyperparathyroidism and Constipation" from Journal of Exotic Pet Medicine
2)
"Constipation in Reptiles" by VeterinaryPartner
3)
"Dehydration" by Beautiful Dragons Reptile Rescue