Just now seeing this but, I totally love toads. I have one right now though I don't know what type s/he is. It was one I rescued from nearly being my cat's play toy in our basement. I've had him almost a month now and he's doing great. He's eating little Dubia roach nymphs and appears to be healthy.
Toads are the BEST! So far in my life, I have owned 11 toads and they were all very cute! Contessa20, I am proud to tell you that you have very healthy toads!
The only time I hold him is to pick him up and move him to his feeding tank. I've always been a little wary of holding frogs and toads too much because of their sensitive skin.