The third one named "Stripes" looks obviously thin and underfed as compared to the 3 year old. Charlie (the second one in the listing) looks a bit thin, but not as bad as Stripes.
He wants $250 for them with the set up. I don't have the space or money to take in Stripes, however if someone can and haggle with this guy, please do. He just looks soo thin (not as bad as other CL beardies but still).