Sorry for the delay. I've been really busy lately and am still playing catch up.
If anything you order from the Beardie Stuff Store has an issue, contact CafePress. They will typically just send you a replacement. I had some coasters I got that were blurry/double imaged, and they just sent me replacements. They're pretty good about that. If they don't take care of your issue, please do let me know.
-Alex